How to Make Your Own Sourdough Starter

Meet Darla my sourdough starter, who’s been my baking buddy since March 2023. I am not a 4th generation baker with a 90+ year old sourdough starter that’s been passed down through my family. I had to figure out how to get one going on my own, and I was too stubborn to buy one online. After three failed attempts to get my very own starter going, I had successfully given Darla life on my 4th attempt.

I believe my first attempt failed due to a lack of patience. The second and third attempts failed due to mold. I believe it got moldy because I used a wooden spoon to mix the starter up. Here is a step by step process on how I created my very own baking buddy, Darla.

Advertisements

Instructions:

First day: mix into a glass 1/2 C whole wheat flour, 1/2 C unbleached all purpose flour, and 1 C filtered water. Stir until well combined. Let the mixture sit for about a day and a half to two days.

Second day: REMOVE half of the mixture and throw it out. Next add to the remaining half: 1/2 C unbleached all purpose flour and 1/2 C filtered water and mix together. Let this mixture sit for about a day. You will want to start keeping an eye out for bubbles in your starter mixture.

Third day: Again remove half of the mixture, and add in 1/2 C unbleached all purpose flour. Now we are going to cut back a hair on the filtered water. I use a flour to water ratio of 1:3/4 when feeding my starter because I personally don’t bother using my scale for feeding. So after you scoop up 1/2 C flour, take that measuring cup and fill it up 3/4s full. You will want to start doing the discard then feed until your sourdough starter takes off and doubles in size in approximately 4-12 hours after a feeding. You can start to use your discard for recipes on about day 4 or 5 if you would like to start testing any discard recipes

Advertisements

Having the right tools and ingredients can make your journey a little bit easier. If you want to see what I use with my sourdough starter, take a look at the list below. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

Weck Jar – I started by using quart sized mason jars, but I found that I spilled flour all over the counter top and sought out to find a better jar. I have been using this Weck Jar for almost a year, and I have been very happy with it. I always recommend this to new sourdough bakers.

Whole Wheat FlourHere is the whole wheat flour I bought for getting my starter going.

Unbleached all purpose flour – I love Costco’s organic unbleached all purpose flour, but in a pinch I use this flour!

Silicon scrapers – I have not had the best luck personally with wooden spoons, so these silicon scrapers are my go-to! They make it very easy to get a good stir and keep my jar clean.

Glass liquid measuring cupThis Pyrex is my go-to when measuring liquid!

Metal measuring cups – These are my favorite measuring cups I use daily in the kitchen.

Advertisements

If you want to get the latest updates from the Family Table Farmstead, enter your email below, thanks!

Family Table Farmstead 🖤

 

← Back

Thank you for your response. ✨

Warning

Leave a comment

I’m Maddie!

Welcome! I am a wife, mom, and foster mom striving for simple living on our little farmstead. I’m somewhere in the middle of the one that went off the deep end and enjoying the conveniences of living in the 21st century.

I love my family, drinking coffee, baking, hiking in the mountains, and learning new things. In 2025, I want to start to learn how to can food, embrace motherhood, start building our new home, and prepare my garden for 2026. Along the way I plan to share stories, lessons learned, and information I feel may be helpful for others!

Let’s connect